Friday, August 22, 2014

Green in foliage, but not necessarily in behavior


As a moderately sustainable student (more so during my undergraduate studies), I couldn’t help but compare and contrast the general ‘greenness’ of Japan as a country and a society. There were some pretty great absences of disposable products in some places, and some egregious uses of them in others.

For instance, the majority of public restaurants and eating establishments offer free glasses of water and green tea with unlimited refills. What’s more, casual/fast dining places (like cafeterias) tend to have automated machines that dispense a pre-measured quantity of ice and water/tea. The volumes dispensed by machine and by hand are generally much smaller (probably half the size or less) than American equivalents, which I could imagine reduces the disposal of excess liquids. Moreover, leftover drinks are usually disposed of in large buckets or chutes near garbage cans/tray return areas, presumably to prevent the aggregation of liquids in trash bags and landfills (perhaps they’re also filtered/purified and recycled?). Recycling and non-recycling trash bins are always available in pairs (notated as non-combustible and combustible, respectively), whereas the only restaurant chain that I know of consistently having recycling bins in the States is Starbucks. However, in public areas, these disposable bins are relatively few and far between – I assume this is because eating and drinking in public are generally considered rude, such that trash on the streets is not expected.

In contrast, public drinking fountains and places to refill reusable water bottles are pretty non-existent. Instead, vending machines can be found at least every few blocks with a variety of canned or bottled beverages from mostly Japanese companies (although Coca Cola has a pretty consistent presence in these machines). While generally cheaper (120 yen on average, or roughly $1.20) per bottle than in America, the overall system seems predisposed to generate an excessive amount of bottle waste. Perhaps this is another reason for the scarcity of trash/recycling bins in public areas – to discourage the purchase of disposable drink containers? (On a side note, another interesting observation I had was how very clean and litter-free the streets were, despite the lack of public disposal bins). As such, I highly recommend bringing a reusable water bottle (and a portable water filter if you’re picky about taste) with you, to fill every morning before leaving your hotel or place of residence. I really liked the Whirlpool Every Drop water filter – it was pretty travel friendly and really quick to filter water. I also brought along my new, trusty, 48-oz Nalgene bottle. Although the full bottle added weight (probably at least a pound) to my backpack, it wasn’t excessive, and I was extremely grateful for the ready supply of water throughout the day. I personally never finished more than one full bottle in a single day, but I’m also not usually one to drink a lot of fluids either (despite the fact that I live in AZ). You could certainly bring a smaller bottle and try to refill it as needed, but I personally didn’t see many places to do so, and definitely didn’t know how to ask for someone to fill it at restaurants. I’m sure it’s possible though.

Obviously, the prevalence of public transportation probably results in a relatively low carbon footprint compared to countries like the United States. However, the sheer density of the population and number of buildings in urban areas might negate some of the green benefits gained by the use of extensive public transportation. I would definitely need to look into the hard numbers and data a bit to really assess this.

Toilet paper and paper towel waste also seem to be significantly lower in Japan than in the States. There are some public restrooms that do not have toilet paper available, and nearly all restrooms do not have paper towels at all. We gathered that most people always have a hand towel with them (for mopping up sweat and, presumably, for drying off wet hands), such that paper towels are not necessary. This seems to be a good tradeoff for the increase in paper waste that’s likely generated by the public transportation system. Although it seems that many citizens have either electronic passes on their phones or reloadable plastic cards to pay for public transportation fares, there are still a large number who buy paper tickets for every trip (tourists especially, I’m sure).

Finally, although it seems that nearly everyone (especially the women) carries some sizeable handbag or backpack sufficient to carry one’s daily purchases, the Japanese are ridiculously big on the packaging of purchased goods. Unless you specifically object, shopkeepers and cashiers will individually wrap or bag each purchased item in paper, and then put all of the items into a larger paper or plastic bag to boot. Even when I showed them that I had my own reusable tote bag, many of the souvenirs that I bought ended up in paper or plastic bags. The only way I was able to consistently reduce the amount of packaging that I accumulated was to say ‘together’ as much as possible. This generally encouraged the baggers to lump like items together into larger bags, i.e. 3 fans in 1 paper bag, instead of wrapping each one individually. Nonetheless, I accumulated an unnecessarily large pile of packaging supplies by the end of the week. If you can research better ways to ask for things to be left unwrapped before you go, I would definitely encourage you to do so in order to cut down on the excess waste.

No comments:

Post a Comment